This matter is before the court for ruling after a trial on the adversary complaint of bmo harris bank n. Confirmation means the entry of the confirmation order by the bankruptcy court on the docket of the chapter 9 case. Federal rules of bankruptcy procedure united states courts. Detroit bankruptcy timeline of events takeover timeline. The inside story behind the largest municipal bankruptcy in u. Detroit bankruptcy could affect city workers nationwide. Detroit bankruptcy could affect city workers nationwide if pensions are cut for detroits workers, the same could happen to workers in other cities. Detroits financial expenses have increased significantly, and that is a direct result of the complex financial deals wall street banks urged on the city over the last several years, even though its precarious cash flow position meant these deals posed a great threat to the city. Do you need advice regarding a michigan chapter 7 bankruptcy. Judge approves detroits exit from bankruptcy usa today. Judge disallows plan by detroit to pay off banks the new. The court is making no ruling whatsoever on whether the city is eligible to be a debtor under chapter 9 or on whether snyder was right to file for bankruptcy given michigans constitutional. Please dont try to do it yourself just because you assume you wont be able to afford an attorney. Although the judge ruled that pensions could be adjusted, fitch does not believe the ruling grants detroits emergency manager unlimited freedom to adjust these obligations.
Everything you need to know about detroits bankruptcy settlement. Bmo objecting to the discharge of chapter 7 debtor charles a. The plainstated thesis in the introduction to nathan bomeys new book, detroit resurrected. The inside story of detroits historic bankruptcy case. The chapter 9 bankruptcy woes that have hit detroit are starting to come to a resolution. Detroits bankruptcy ruling is good news for bondholders, and unlikely to inspire more filings. Judge disallows plan by detroit to pay off banks the new york times. While this filing is viewed as the result of highly idiosyncratic factors e. Detroit came up with a variety of creative fiscal solutions meant to benefit various subsets of its creditors, and, at least for now, it appears to have obtained the bankruptcy courts blessing. Eastern district of michigan united states bankruptcy court. Confirmation date means the date on which the bankruptcy court enters the confirmation order on the docket in the chapter 9 case, within the meaning of bankruptcy rules 5003 and 9021. Detroit bankruptcy said unconstitutional business insider. Rhodes agreed with unions and pension funds that the citys emergency manager, kevyn orr, had not negotiated in good faith in the weeks ahead of the july filing, a key condition under federal law. Detroit is also the largest city by population in the u.
Detroit usa was considered to be a city that epitomised the american dream of industrial development as the driver of economic growth and city development. By order dated april 24, 1973, effective october 1, 1973, the supreme court prescribed, pursuant to 28 u. Bryan jacoutot ably explored the core reason for the motor citys recently fiscal crash. Michigan court clears way for detroit bankruptcy to proceed. United states bankruptcy court northern district of. Court tosses challenges to detroits bankruptcy cnbc.
Rhodes ruling was a surprising rejection of a deal rosen had personally endorsed and that his mediators had fought hard to secure. Judge steven rhodes believes that a ruling on the bankruptcy issues will end sometime during the week of november 3rd, with proceedings starting as early as october 27th. This case discusses the positioning of detroit as an industrial city, the short sightedness of city managers, the factors that led to the bankruptcy of the city particularly the mismanagement. Despite the glut of news reports published over detroits 18 months in the throes of bankruptcy court, this appears to be the first book to tell the full story of the. As a former citizen of the detroit area, i simply shake my head, as the citys racebased politics and poor business environment caused me to flee to the golden state over 20 years ago. Kenneth klee, the bankruptcy lawyer who spearheaded the bankruptcy restructuring of jefferson county, alabama, said a state judge cant force detroit out of federal bankruptcy, even if snyder. The federal bankruptcy judge overseeing detroits municipal bankruptcy case will announce on dec. The world socialist web site also spoke to robert, a retired detroit bus mechanic, who denounced the imposition of an emergency manager and the. Detroit presents a study in the lessons of a large municipal bankruptcy. A federal judge in michigan ruled on tuesday that detroit can cut public pensions as it enters bankruptcy. Children play in the sand at campus martius park in downtown detroit, michigan, u. The latest news and comment on the detroit bankruptcy february 2016. Detroit bankruptcy ruling nears the end own it detroit.
Bankruptcy costs detroit retirees local news detroit. Detroit once the very symbol of american industrial might, detroit became the biggest u. On thursday, july 18, 20 the city of detroit filed a petition seeking bankruptcy protection and the adjustment of debts under chapter 9 of the united states bankruptcy code. The petition was filed in the united states bankruptcy court for the eastern district of michigan, southern division, and was assigned case number 53846. Debtburdened cities around the country are studying a major court decision. Though the bankruptcy case was ultimately resolved with deals struck with detroits major creditors, the notion of bankruptcy had irked many city leaders, who initially accused the states. For many years, such proceedings were governed by the general orders and forms in bankruptcy promulgated by the supreme court. How to file bankruptcy in michigan without a lawyer. A federal judge announced on tuesday that detroit is eligible for bankruptcy protection the first time in us history that a major city has been declared bust. Detroit was ruled eligible for chapter 9 bankruptcy today. Detroit granted bankruptcy protection after judge rules in. Plan to exit bankruptcy is approved for detroit the new. What happened in detroit must never happen again, judge steven w. In a decision that surprised many, a bankruptcy judge said it was reasonably likely that detroit could free itself of costly swap contracts if it sued the two banks holding them.
Access to bankruptcy court currently serves clients in the eastern district of michigan. Sdcers detroits bankruptcy ruling and its relevance to. Again, i strongly encourage you to use an attorney whenever possible. Tucker in the united states bankruptcy court, eastern district of michigan. The ruling, which will be issued in print later this month, puts an end to the largest municipal bankruptcy in u.
The michigan court of appeals on tuesday ordered a temporary halt to three lawsuits that seek to derail detroits municipal bankruptcy, after the states attorney general sought to overturn lower. The customer service information line for detroit is 3 2340065, flint is 810 2354126 and bay city is 989 8948840. John steinberger is a board certified bankruptcy attorney with over 30 years of experience. The ruling by rhodes that public employee pensions could be reduced in chapter 9 bankruptcy was a landmark decision, says john pottow, a university of michigan law school professor who. After municipal bankruptcy the pew charitable trusts. Detroit bankruptcy ca cities bankruptcy imapct of ruling. The ruling by the detroit bankruptcy judge created new law that is likely to be appealed, with no final decision for some time. Detroit retirees put on notice in bankruptcy ruling.
City of detroit bankruptcy filing eastern district of. After detroits close call a court ruling saved the dias artworkbut other museums whose works are governmentowned might not be so lucky. If you are looking for a michigan bankruptcy attorney, john steinberger and his team have the experience you need. Detroit has filed for chapter 9 bankruptcy youtube. When a paper filing has been authorized under the ecf procedures, only the original must be filed, except that the debtor must file an original and one copy of a chapter 9 petition or a chapter 11 petition. Fitch published a research note on the bankruptcy ruling and concluded that detroits ruling would not lead to a spate of local bankruptcies in michigan. Welcome to the official website containing information for the city of detroit bankruptcy filing for the united states bankruptcy court for the eastern district of michigan. That ruling made detroit the largest city in american history to officially go bankrupt.
The rulings significance is that union workers across the u. This is the story of what happens when a great american city goes broke. The city of detroit, michigan, filed for chapter 9 bankruptcy on july 18, 20. Regardless of the detroit ruling s immediate impact, sdcers has sufficient funds to pay its current and future retirees for decades to come, even if no additional plan sponsor contributions were received. Everything you need to know about detroits bankruptcy. Bmo contends that within one year of his bankruptcy case, brahos transferred to his wife his. To bankruptcy and back, belies its wrenching detail. It is the largest municipal bankruptcy filing in u. The milestone ruling could affect the retirement of millions of current and former municipal workers. Stuart sandweiss, metro detroit bankruptcy law group, southfield, michigan, attorney for debtor.
1642 1262 1384 72 1364 1285 314 963 1183 1005 1651 1665 669 1445 839 234 159 1535 580 429 205 1459 152 1280 752 1462 1257 764 1351 1219 813 906 877 107 1394 415 1151 960 686 1148 1104 1172